War Machines
âEngineers of Victory,â by Paul Kennedy
The historian Daniel Boorstin once complained to me about the Smithsonian Institutionâs decision in 1980 to delete the final two words from the name of its Museum of History and Technology. Boorstin had a point. Scholars of other fields do often tend to underestimate the influence of technology. Although most of us know that World War II brought us radar, the literature of that titanic conflict is by no means exempt from this phenomenon. For instance, the biographer Joseph P. Lash subtitled his 1976 wartime account of Franklin Roosevelt and Winston Churchill âThe Partnership That Saved the West,â in response to which I once heard a British scholar carp, âIf Lash is right, then why did all those scientists and intelligence officers and factory workers bother working so hardâ
ENGINEERS OF VICTORY
The Problem Solvers Who Turned the Tide in the Second World War
By Paul Kennedy
Illustrated. 436 pp. Random House. $30.
With this fresh and discursive new work, the Yale historian Paul Kennedy, best known for his widely debated âRise and Fall of the Great Powers,â published in 1987, calls attention to the way âsmall groups of individuals and institutionsâ surmounted seemingly insuperable operational obstacles to enable Roosevelt, Truman, Churchill and Stalin ultimately to grasp the laurels for an Allied triumph. âEngineers of Victoryâ achieves the difficult task of being a consistently original book about one of the most relentlessly examined episodes in human history. Unlike most studies of the war, this one is not primarily about politics, generalship or battlefield glories. References to the Big Three are few. Instead, like an engineer who pries open a pocket watch to reveal its inner mechanics, Kennedy tells how Âlittle-known men and women at lower Âlevels helped win the war.
Kennedy concentrates mainly on the European theater and on Allied progress during the period from early 1943, when Hitlerâs Admiral Doenitz sank 108 Allied vessels in a single month, provoking fears that England would be starved of essential bunker fuel, to the almost fantastic summer of 1944, when British and American troops scrambled onto Festung Europa. By Kennedyâs telling, a number of concurrent accomplishments spelled the difference between victory and, if not defeat, then, at least, a struggle that might have dragged on past 1945, with countless additional casualties.
The first was ensuring that Allied convoys could cross the Atlantic without being sunk by Germans. As Kennedy acknowledges, this was the first war in which sea powerâs success was decided by air power, so part of the solution was cranking out airplanes (especially long-range bombers). But vital too were innovations like the Hedgehog, a forward-firing ship-Âmounted mortar (devised by an idiosyncratic British unit called âWheezers and Dodgersâ), and the Leigh Light, which exposed German U-boats that were surfacing at night to recharge batteries so that British bombers could do their deadly work. In contrast with the cadre of popular and scholarly authors who since the 1970s have written, often breathlessly, about glamorous code breakers, Kennedy is skeptical of Bletchley Parkâs importance, because the intelligence operation known as Ultra âcould do only so much.â
Command of the air over Germany was seized only when American squadrons arrived to augment the Royal Air Force, upend the existing British doctrine of restricting attacks to nighttime and demand pinpoint bombing of specifically identified German military and industrial targets. The zenith of Allied accomplishment in the air, of course, was D-Day 1944, when a previously unimaginable 11,590 planes were sent aloft. âThere had been nothing like it in world history,â Kennedy writes, ânor has there been since. . . . There was no chance for the completely diminished Luftwaffe to do anything except lose more and more of its planes and pilots whenever they rose into the air.â Kennedy goes on to describe how the Allies stopped the ferocious blitzkrieg assaults of 1939 to 1942 by deploying âstronger, tougher and better-equipped forces (with panzers, bazookas, mines, better tactical aircraft)â in concert with the western thrust of the Soviet Army, aided by their T-34-85, which Kennedy calls the âmost all-rund battle tankâ of the war.
Victory in Europe before the summer of 1945 also required the Allies to make hasty progress in perfecting the art of amphibious warfare. After World War I, Kennedy notes, with âa badly defeated and much-Âreduced Germany, in a badly damaged and scarcely victorious France and Italy, and in an infant Soviet Union, there were many thoughts of war, but none of them involved the projection of force across the oceans.â The disheartening debacle of the one-day Allied trial effort in August 1942 to breach the Atlantic Wall with a raid against the modest German garrison at Dieppe, France, provided crucial lessons that led directly to the world-Âimportant success on D-Day two years later.
Michael Beschloss, the author, most recently, of âPresidential Courage,â is writing a history of American presidential leadership in wartime.
A version of this review appeared in print on February 10, 2013, on page BR15 of the Sunday Book Review with the headline: War Machines.